We offer unparalleled service and competitive quotes to
clients throughout the entire State of New York!

About Us

We are an Insurance Company based in Stony Brook, New York. Our ultimate goal is to create lasting relationships with each of our clients so that we may continue providing excellent service for many years to come.

The Mill Creek Agency, Inc Team is committed to providing clients with the highest quality insurance plans available combined with some of the lowest rates available in all of New York. Whether you’re shopping for auto insurance, home insurance, health, life or business insurance, we can help get you the best coverage available with the lowest rate possible.


Mill Creek

Mill Creek has been servicing your insurance needs for 14 years. Through our consultation with you, we determine your specific needs and create programs that precisely match them. And, no matter how large or modest those needs may be, our goal is to help you manage and plan for all your potential risks. We want to simplify and clarify the entire process for you. Our commitment to detail provide clients the satisfaction of knowing they are getting the best protection at the best price. We’re determined to exceed your expectations and be the last insurance brokerage you’ll ever need

Ask about a quote

Our Coverages

Rely on us for personal lines and commercial policies including:


It's where you find the most rest. Get home Insurance for the place you love.


Accidents can happen when you least expect them - Be ready!


We’re by your side to help take care of those you love most.


We're here to make sure you have the right coverage for your possesions.


Insurance that protects your company, so you can get back to business.

Group Health for Businesses

We make finding the right health insurance easy and convenient.

Intrested in a quote?

Feel free to email us and we would be happy to help you!

Ask about a quote!


We work with many carriers to bring you the best rate on your policy!

Hartford Insurance

Mapfre Insurance

National General Insurance

Safeco Insurance

Wright Flood

Interboro Insurance

Merchants Insurance

Ocean Harbor Insurance

Travelers Insurance

Kingstone Insurance

Narraganset Bay Insurance

Progressive Insurance

Us Coastal

And many more!

Fun Facts About Us

  • 25

    Years of service
  • 30000


    Policies Written
  • 3

    Years of 'Long Island's Best'
  • 7000

    Cups Of Coffee